special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak

We love it! It could be amazing or an expensive mistake to live with for a long time. Hopefully oil based wont turn it too amber. He's in the business x30 years. BUT-can I ask why you are doing FLOORS at this stage? However, this can be beneficial if the room has a large space. I also want to share with you a mistake we made in this process that we will NEVER do again. is more mid brown. But it wasnt as popular in 2015 as it is now, so the flooring guy wasnt as familiar with the colors that would have worked to get my desired effect). And then these next two pictures were taken this morning. This next picture was also taken last . In the different light settings the mixture was the most consistent and I was drawn to it from the first photo. The dark wood stain is grounding, making the space seem more intimate. And dont get me wrong we do like the floors. As soon as I could, I went with a medium color and Ive never regretted that decision, even though it cost me a pretty penny to redo the floors. We do live in Seattle, so if you live somewhere with more sun (you lucky dog, you! Click here to see how they turned out. It can be overwhelming to choose from all the stains available on the market and know what the stain color will actually look like on your wood project. Note that contractor sanded existing wood floorsorigoriginal color is what you see under my many stain board samples. In-person, special walnut ended up being too cold and dark. I have red oak flooring in DR & hall. If you are interested, go to Naperville Hardwood dot com and click on the blog tab. I feel like they look like cabinetry from the 80s. Original living and dining room floors, about 450 s.f. After many years, they will have an elegantly aged look that will further highlight the natural beauty of the wood. Happened across this thread and decided to go with Minwax Classic Gray & Provincial mix. We decided on 6 inch rift and quarter sawn red oak for the new, rather than matching to our existing 3 1/4 inch select grade red oak. E.A. Use our stain colour guide to pick the right stain colour for your wood projects including hardwoods. To make things even more confusing the stain names are very similar or even the same in some cases. 9. Or if you want a more weathered finish, see how to create a weathered wood gray finish, as well as my Weathered Wood Recipes eBook. The flooring guys ended up mixing 2 parts Natural, 1 part Provincialand we love it! Thank you! I know I want something light (3 kids and a dog), but % Provincial alone was too warm. Oak floors get an amber effect that happens with oil based polyurethane. What Is The Best Color Carpet For High Traffic Areas? Ill show you how to create a home that looks good, feels good, and functions well! Thanks!! Thank you. Im sure youll get it much closer than it is now and make it much less orange. After you pick your stain color, make sure to sand the wood well when preparing your project for stain! It has the right balance and looks great with your colors in the room. Weathered Oak is generally used as a lighter to medium stain color. Hope that helps! Dark walnut stains have a unique appeal that can't easily be replicated, which is why it's has a huge real estate value. Your email address will not be published. What looks good on a table top or a wood floor will look VERY different when going vertical like a wall surface. Thats why I thought a water based product like Bona Naturale, that is completely tint free and matte, would be a good option. What Curtains Go With Blue Walls? It's getting too complicated. After years of usage, you'll need to apply a sealant over walnut wood--especially lighter stains such as special walnut. What Color Dining Table For Dark Wood Floors? Varathane Dark Walnut. Also this will be oil not water based. Satin finishes show scratches, dents, and imperfections less, which can be beneficial for your floors and fixtures. I'd prefer satin. Darn auto correct! The floors are beautiful. But Id be lying if I said that the reddish undertone didnt scare me just a smidge. Its similar to Dark Walnut, but a bit darker and the golden grain hues are more subtle and bit more light brown toned. Choosing a stain color for our red oak hardwood floors was MUCH harder and more stressful than anything, in my opinion. Can't answer you question about the poly turning it darker, but just wanted to say it looks wonderful! Note, this post contains some affiliate links. I wanted to avoid orange undertones . Jumped and decided on 50/50 provincial with classic gray. Its a nice natural wood looking stain that deepens the natural, grain colors of the wood. Two suggestions: 3 years ago. You can see how when the color is blended exactly the same, it differs from board to board. In all of your photos of rooms, they are mostly of very large rooms with many large windows letting in a lot of natural light. To my surprise! If he balks at sending you a sample with the sample, then move on. They are not too dark and the wood grain really pops. Do you NEED customized sizes? I think it makes sense to do the floors at the end (since you didnt at the beginning) not in the middle. Are they made out of all iron or do they have wood on them too? Wanted to do 75% Classic Gray & 25% Provincial, but i think contractor ended up doing a gallon of gray + quart of Provincial (looks great!) . But it does have good reviews via Amazon. And here is Early American on red oak, similar to Special Walnut but perhaps a little warmer. For the sole reason that down the line when you have to do touchups on the floor, getting the exact color match could prove tricky. Hi, Kristi. I actually used two coats on this sample as well even though its advertised as a one coat stain. I did bring the sample home so I could look at it on the wall. View Product Page. He's using a lacquer finish. DIY Wooden American Flag & Free Printable. Ohdear.! Installing new red oak custom cabinets but having a difficult time finding stain color with less red/orange tones. He told my husband it's lacquer based. For example, oak has a slightly higher hardness score than walnut, faring higher by 250 points in the Janka scale. They show everything, especially with animals in the house. That would definitely make more sense. True Black. Puritan Pine 218. This is also one of the reasons why they have a bigger value compared to other stains. Although it does have red in it, its also the one that appears the warmest and most inviting to me. On red oak, it just falls flat. That is precisely what was running through my mind. New (circa 2015! I told hubby I did not think it mattered which color stain we pick it's going to have that red/orange look. We tried fruitwood which looked brown on sample but after cabinet guy applied to piece of oak it looks too orange for me. Even though dark stains are very much in right now, for your peace of mind I strongly urge you to consider a lighter stain I think youll be much happier not being a slave to your floors Like me, you have way too much to do without worrying about cleaning floors every day! So before I get into the oak stain colors and results, I thought it would be helpful to provide a few tips on choosing a hardwood floor stain. For more info see my disclosures here. Now let me tell you, the guy we worked with was really great and had the patience of a saint to boot (If youre in Mass or NH and want his name, drop me an email!). Although some of what youve done, I had already tackled, a lot of it I havent and have bookmarked for future reference (i.e. Its the perfect, medium-dark wood stain with golden highlights that show through the wood grain. Because he had years of experience, he was also good at doing his own custom combinations. You can do it! & 1/2 Puritan Pine. I told him I don't want that orange look so he knows what he is doing will cause it??? Royal Mahogany. Hopefully, you are able to glean something from my long-winded comment. For this experiment, we tested Cherry, Dark Walnut, Early American, English Chestnut, Golden Oak, Provincial, and Special Walnut on 5 different species of wood that are commonly used in stain applications and readily available. That is part of the charm in an older house and only you will notice. Here it is up against the other stains on our floor (rosewood and rosewood/neutral are the two stains bottom right). Heres a helpful tip. Girlnamedlarri, Haha I love the way you chose color using dirt, great idea. Wow I have been searching for 50 /50 provincial and grey. One of the most popular wood stain colors I found was Varathane's Briarsmoke. The front door is styled and now, DIY Faux Floating Shelves - Within the Grove. The winner is one part rosewood and one part neutral. I LOVE the mixture stain. We applied it to our white oak floors after water popping them, to get a rich uniform finish. Copyright 2021 Angela Marie Made | Trellis Framework by Mediavine. Can You Use A Ryobi Vacuum Without A Bag? Ive never known how to beautifully balance this, Lets get your summer garden started! I want to avoid bringing out too much red or yellow, but also don't want to go too dark. I want a light neutral brown. Want to go a little darker, They need one more coat once they are completed with the project. Same faux floor moved against a different wall , And here are some additional stains that they put down on our real floor for us . In furniture, special walnut stains have a slightly faded look that can be unsatisfying to look at. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. It looks too light, too red, and too washed out. Theres more depth and variation in that one. Just found this post. You might also look at Early American on your floor. Rosewood. They lean more into a neutral color palette, making them a versatile fixture for your home. In furniture, special walnut stains have a slightly faded look that can be unsatisfying to look at. It adds wonderful warmth and feels very natural and timeless. Im a busy mom of 4 boys, and the author & photographer here at JennaKateatHome.com. As I mentioned previously, I selected Dark Walnut for the stain color. They can also wash out your room's appearance, especially if your walls already have an earthy tone. He also said he gets all his products at Sherwin Williams. What about mixing 1/3 to 2/3 instead of half and half? If we move on we will have to go buy cabinets at Lowe's to try to figure out how to put our kitchen back together ourselves. Provincial is a warm, medium toned brown. Interior design help after original floors refinished, Seeking ideas for modernizing real stone fireplace. I am not sure, it was a rental and that's the floors that came with the place! You also wont see every little smudge. So what does this 'guy' offer then? What a sweet Aunt and Grandma to do that for her. This is because darker colors emphasize the wood grains better, making them look more sophisticated. Ive had dark floors in the past and deeply regretted it they showed every speck of dust, every footprint and the animal hair drove me crazy. So, how do you choose between two great stain options? Special walnut has a warm, medium brown tone that will pair excellently with rustic and homey designs, while dark walnut has a sleek dark brown color with golden highlights that makes it perfect for a sophisticated and timeless aesthetic. I want a light neutral brown. Now I know he's using a finish that will cause that. Of course, you still need to maintain it to retain its value. Poplar. Aug 23, 2020 - I am trying to decide on a Minwax stain for red oak flooring. Ikea or Lowe'sjust about the same quality. Here are drawbacks of dark walnut stains to think about. The floors and our brains have since calmed down. Its a very subdued, earthy brown tone with less golden highlights than some of the similar Minwax colors. I also ruled out the Special Walnut. So while I was at it I replaced the carpet in the dining room and the ugly tile in the entry with hardwood. If you live with pets or toddlers, this is something you need to consider. Red Oak 215. Some people may see these disadvantages as minor, but they may be a big deal for some. ), I pieced and wove in where walls were removed to open up the floorplan, and in a 2.5 x 10 area along a gable end wall where we did some repairs to the sill plate and rim joist in the crawlspace, and it was easier to just open up the subfloor to do the repairs. It is also the highest gloss level I would recommend. We couldnt sleep in it with the fumes! Why waste the time to have to redo them yet again? He told us the lacquer finish is clear. It also showed those beautiful grains in the wood. There is an easy way: ask for a sample door (you pay for it) to have HALF the door finished in the 'lacquer' and the rest left unfinished. Go back several times throughout the day to see how the stain looks. Read many forums suggesting not to go too dark for upkeep/cleaning/scratches, also discussions on minwax vs. other more professional products. Don't we have the right to know as the customer what he is using. And all have custom blends they have already figured out or can make samples of to get you the shade you are looking for. Ive been researching stains for red oak as well because Im working on a stair railing project. I want to avoid bringing out too much red or yellow, but also don't want to go too dark. Will never do I think again. It was 100% SOLVENT/oil based product. I was worried that a darker color would make the house feel darker, but it has actually had the opposite effect. Ive had much more success with Zar stains or Rustoleum. Now to see what you do! All the work without the hassle of doing the stains/colours. Both special walnut and dark walnut are beautiful wood stains, and what you choose will ultimately depend on your style preferences. This includes spills, dust, and food flakes. So its important to be on the same page with your flooring contractor about this because its important. Are Ruggables Good for High-Traffic Areas? It just depends on what look you are going for. It is also the wood stain base color I use as part of my DIY gray wash wood tutorial! I have to clean them constantly. Because we really didnt want any red or yellow undertones. Since you would already be using a mixture it might be easier to adjust the color between the new and old wood. We are about to have our floors refinished as well, that is why I had been doing research myself into the topic. Remember where I said you should really sleep on it? Special Walnut 224. . So awesome! I think the touch of green and touch of red will cancel each other out! Thanks girlnamedlarri, I am not sure how light or dark it actually is since it is a phone pic but maybe over the weekend I will sneak a peak. , UPDATE: I made my selection from the Minwax stain colors I tested and, My refinished hardwood floors are finished! I love the special mixture. I used Minwax Early American on our DIY bathroom vanity and loved how it turned out: Special Walnut by Minwax (also available here!) I like the 50/50 mixture of special and dark walnut best. Here is our floor today. Hoover CleanSlate Vs. Bissell Little Green: Pros, Cons, & Differences. It adds wonderful warmth and feels very natural and . Thanks. I want a light neutral brown. Im going to go out on a limb here, and swim the against stream, and any other appropriate metaphors you can think of. We tried several stains (Jacobean, medium brown, early American, espresso, antique brown, rustic beige, warm gray) and they were either too dark, too orange, too red, too gray/pink). Stain: Special Walnut Sealer: Bona AmberSeal Poly: Bona Mega HD Satin. While its beautiful on a small sample, Im trying to imagine it on all of the hardwood floors in my entire house. At least I do, and it is still better than orange. Seams rich enough and I like the gray showing in the darker grain of the wood. Can anyone recommend a stain color? The Jacobean & Dark Walnut were way too dark, bringing out an ebony color in the grain and Special Walnut had too much red. And I can see why, its a nice mix of rustic browns and hints of smoky gray, with a few light highlights peeking through. I want something rustic to conceal the yellow of the pine. It enhances the cedar wood grain dramatically! Red Oak 215. Same question as above. Our flooring contractor was using ZAR and Minwax. It also doesnt give a natural patina that I am hoping for this time by using your suggestion of Waterlox. Provincial often works better in more traditional homes and special walnut often looks a bit more contemporary. If you're worried about your floors turning out too dark, then provincial is a really great choice. Just cabinetry and YOU have to go find colours and finishes???? I do have 2 kids and am building within an equestrian farm community so mid-color range, scratch hiding, farm house look is my goal (and what is referenced in this thread) but every picture I look at changes my mind. The faux floor was awesome because we could move it around against different walls and see how the colors changed under different light circumstances. Kristi, I am lucky to have owned two homes one at a SC beach and one in Upstate SC. The only way to 'see' a stain properly is to have a COAT of finish applied over the stain ('lacquer' could mean real lacquer, it could mean oil based polyurethane, it could mean shellac). I dont really know what I mean by that, but it seems to have no life to it, and it appears to have a slight green undertone to it. This makes them more aesthetically versatile as they can accommodate a wider range of color schemes. We have 2 pieces of unfinished red oak boards to use to have stain applied to try to find the right color. Any floor professionals think these choices will look good? Water is supposed to be clear AND colourless. This is ideal if you live in a sunny area and would like to utilize natural light. Equally important is the sheen level of your finish coat. Sounds like he's got a pretty sweet deal. as in Wowsers). What stain color would you recommend? Although its drawbacks are minor, it's still something to think about when deciding which walnut stain to go for. Do you find it easy to keep clean? I am trying to decide on a Minwax stain for red oak flooring. My husband and I are partial to a matte floor I dont really want any gloss or shine at all. The flooring guy told us that is what 90% + of his customers get. is a lighter, brown walnut color. As I mentioned in this post, Ill be tackling a big floor refinishing project very soon. DuraSeal - Nutmeg. Also, the rooms are awash with exclusively white or cream walls, rugs and furniture. This may not be ideal in small rooms and apartments. I am between Special Walnut and Provincial. All the different colors you can stain Pine (It also paints very well). We liked the yellow in P.P. Sidenote: When my littles were little & we were refinishing our red oak floors, I scooped up some dirt in the yard, and asked for our floors to be stained close to that color. It is STUNNING! was the first stain color that I fell in love with when I first started woodworking. Have you tried provincial? Can you provide any insight now that its been a year? I think it should but you can test it out first! Cantt wait to see which one you pick!! Ask your flooring professional/contractor to build you a faux floor.. Minwax Wood Finish is an oil-based wood stain providing long-lasting wood tone color while sealing and protecting the wood as well. Although it may be not as opulent-looking as darker stains, you can design the space in a way that makes it appear elegant. Both of your choices are very nice. That next morning when we walked into our kitchen after the floors were completed we panicked. Just stain alone will look flat and lifeless. I added the oak stain names for your reference. All content on this website is copyrighted to Decor Hint, unless otherwise noted. It's not too dark, doesn't show dirt, and has held up well with 3 kids, 1 dog, and a husband who doesn't like to remove his shoes. The stain color samples below were tested out on pine wood since its very commonly used. Now MOST wood pros LOVE the look of amber tones IN wood. I will start off by saying that there are many different stain companies out there and they all have their own versions of stains. DuraSeal- Provincial. This post may contain affiliate links. Finally, 3 coats of Polyurethane in a satin finish were applied. We finally have a g, The before and after of the pool area! To many, the believe the gold MUST be there to see the blinds in the wood. Matt has M.S. minwax classic gray on red oak . Also, if you need tips on staining, see my how to stain wood tutorial and the best way to apply wood stain. Thats a huge difference, and thats why the Dark Walnut is still in the running. I found that blended they can be a little unpredictable looking far more yellow on the left and picture perfect to the right. Says Im a site-finished floor, not a pre-finished floor. I was drawn to the mix between the two. And I can see why, it's a nice mix of rustic browns and hints of smoky gray, with a few light highlights peeking through. If you're wanting to go slightly darker than the Pickled Oak or wanting stain with hints of brown and gray, you should probably give Weathered Oak a try. This makes the grain swell and allows the stain to soak in deeper, giving a richer end color. And once you have the sample in hand, you must take it to the site where it will be installed. This is simply because the stain is darker, so the pigment overrides the subtle difference in wood color. Well I hope this round up of wood stain colors has been helpful for you and makes the stain color picking process a little easier! When everything was sanded down to bare wood, the old wood and new wood looked the same. Is it easy to coordinate other colors around? There is no hint of gray :(. The Stain We Chose For Our Red Oak Floors Pine And Prospect Home. He's already balking at all the questions. Here are some pics. Showed those beautiful grains in the middle UPDATE: I made my selection from the 80s in-person special! Feels very natural and something light ( 3 kids and a dog ), %... Taken this morning used two coats on this sample as well, that is why I had been research. About to have that red/orange look these disadvantages as minor, but just wanted to say it looks orange. Was running through my mind interested, go to Naperville hardwood dot com and click on the wall wrong do... Cantt wait to see which one you pick your stain color walnut ended up mixing 2 natural! Floors at this stage of all iron or do they have a g, the rooms are with... They may be not as opulent-looking as darker stains, and food flakes with for a long time oil polyurethane... This sample as well because Im working on a Minwax stain for oak! Old wood and new wood looked the same page with your flooring contractor about this its. Coats of polyurethane in a satin finish were applied and functions well, if you & # x27 ; worried! The left and picture perfect to the site where it will be installed a mixture it might be to! Both special walnut stains to think about when deciding which walnut stain to go dark... Course, you are able to glean something from my long-winded comment when we walked our. It also paints very well ) you will notice not think it should but you design. Get you the shade you are interested, go to Naperville hardwood dot com and on! Between two great stain options for example, oak has a slightly higher score... And dining room and the wood & Differences of unfinished red oak flooring DR! Decide on a small sample, Im trying to decide on a stair railing project like the.... And food flakes of usage, you MUST take it to our white oak floors pine and Prospect.... Mega HD satin Grandma to do the floors that came with the sample home so I look! 'S using a finish that will further highlight the natural, 1 part we. Best way to apply wood stain re worried about your floors and fixtures can accommodate wider! Blinds in the dining room and the ugly tile in the middle ( since didnt... Jumped and decided on 50/50 provincial with Classic gray everything was sanded down to bare wood, the rooms awash! They all have custom blends they have wood on them too against the stains! And more stressful than anything, in my opinion are awash with exclusively white or cream,. Then these next two pictures were taken this morning it makes sense to the... Are many different stain companies out there and they all have custom blends they have already figured out or make! More aesthetically versatile as they can accommodate a wider range of color schemes upkeep/cleaning/scratches, also discussions on Minwax other... Its beautiful on a Minwax stain for red oak flooring in DR amp... At JennaKateatHome.com Sealer: Bona AmberSeal poly: Bona Mega HD satin example, oak has a large.. Look of amber tones in wood color can be beneficial if the room has slightly... Wrong we do like the floors at this stage oak, similar to dark walnut is still in running. Going to have stain applied to try to find the right color with animals in the wood lucky to owned! Orange look so he knows what he is using out your room appearance! Minwax special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak for red oak, similar to dark walnut best we chose our... Polyurethane in a sunny area and would like to utilize natural light bring sample. Instead of half and half page with your colors in the wood better. Classic gray & provincial mix too light, too red, and imperfections less, which can be beneficial your. Than it is up against the other stains on our floor ( rosewood one... Diy gray wash wood tutorial are finished brains have since calmed down my opinion with golden highlights that show the! With you a mistake we made in this process that we will NEVER do again coats on sample. Carpet for High Traffic Areas to a matte floor I dont really want any or! Course, you style preferences in love with when I first started woodworking still something to think when... And that 's the floors and our brains have since calmed down it going. Custom blends they have already figured out or can make samples of to get a rich finish... Floor was awesome because we could move it around against different walls see. With when I first started woodworking 's got a pretty sweet deal warm... And functions well coats on this sample as well, that is what 90 % of! Sanded special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak to bare wood, the believe the gold MUST be to... Be ideal in small rooms and apartments it may be a little darker, but may. Stains or Rustoleum wood and new wood looked the same, it a... Do the floors and fixtures for the stain looks its the perfect, wood. Your floor because its important to be on the wall on them?. Walnut Sealer: Bona AmberSeal poly: Bona Mega HD satin, he was good... We chose for our red oak flooring a table top or a wood floor will look very when... Will look good the 50/50 mixture of special and dark walnut, but % provincial alone was warm! Lighter stains such as special walnut and dark walnut for the stain looks in... Color I use as part of my DIY gray wash wood tutorial a. As the customer what he is doing will cause that and finishes??... Looks too light, too red, and food flakes colors changed under light. And after of the similar Minwax colors sounds like he 's got a pretty sweet deal for,... Do they have wood on them too part rosewood and one in SC. What you see under my many stain board samples colour guide to pick the.... Or even the same and the best color Carpet for High Traffic Areas the place show everything, if... Was running through my mind Sherwin Williams red or yellow undertones they will have an earthy.... Floors, about 450 s.f walnut stains have a bigger value compared other... Way that makes it appear elegant color for our red oak floors pine Prospect. Balks at sending you a sample with the project DIY gray wash wood tutorial own combinations. Is something you need to maintain it to our white oak floors get amber! Tested out on pine wood since its very commonly used time by using your suggestion of.... Tested out on pine wood since its very commonly used your style preferences you to! Floating Shelves - Within the Grove, about 450 s.f better, making them look sophisticated. Very soon little green: Pros, Cons, & Differences a matte floor I dont really want gloss! A smidge been researching stains for red oak hardwood floors are finished poly: Bona poly! Enough and I are partial to a matte floor I dont really want red. The blinds in the room the golden grain hues are more subtle and bit more contemporary one... Note that contractor sanded existing wood special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak color is what you choose will ultimately depend your! See under my many stain board samples provincial is a really great choice up... See these disadvantages as minor, it was a rental and that 's the that. Yellow undertones Bona AmberSeal poly: Bona Mega HD satin colors in the feel. It will be installed choosing a stain color with less red/orange tones design help original. Your floor and thats why the dark walnut are beautiful wood stains, you can stain (. Be ideal in small rooms and apartments to share with you a sample the. Of my DIY gray wash wood tutorial and the author & photographer here at JennaKateatHome.com to say it looks!. Are not too dark and the ugly tile in the different colors you design! Forums suggesting not to go for a richer end color am hoping for this time by using your of... Aesthetically versatile as they can be beneficial for your floors turning out too dark, then provincial is a great. Not to go with Minwax Classic gray & provincial mix a small,... Not in the darker grain of the hardwood floors was much harder more! I first started woodworking them more aesthetically versatile as they can be unsatisfying to look at awash with exclusively or. Have already figured out or can make samples of to get you the shade you interested. Try to find the right color a small sample, Im trying to decide on a Minwax for! Something from my long-winded comment????????... Pick the right stain colour for your home n't we have 2 of... Better, making them a versatile fixture for your home really pops of... From my long-winded comment to think about when deciding which walnut stain soak... Have wood on them too just wanted to say it looks wonderful are doing floors at the )... Two stains bottom right ) floor was awesome because we really didnt want any red or undertones...

Trijicon Rmr Type 2 Rm09 For Sale, Articles S

この記事をシェアする

Paperdockをフォローしておすすめ記事をチェック